AI Generated Content

Image generated by gemini-3-pro-image-preview in the style of XKCD - with apologies to Randall Munroe

Introduction

“Nightshade” marks the beginning of a new series by renowned crime fiction author Michael Connelly. Stepping away from his iconic Los Angeles settings of the Harry Bosch and Mickey Haller novels, Connelly transports readers to Santa Catalina Island, a resort destination twenty-two miles off the coast of California. The novel introduces a new protagonist, Detective Sergeant Stilwell, a formidable investigator exiled to this insular community. Combining the atmospheric tension of a closed-circle mystery with Connelly’s signature procedural realism, “Nightshade” explores the dark underbelly of a picturesque tourist trap.

Overview of the Story

The narrative centers on Detective Sergeant Stilwell, a homicide detective who has been “exiled” to the Catalina Sheriff’s station following a professional fallout with a colleague on the mainland. Stilwell’s hope for a quiet tenure is shattered by two disturbing events: the discovery of a young woman’s body in Avalon Bay and the bizarre beheading of a protected buffalo.

The victim, Leigh-Anne Moss, is found weighted down by an anchor and wrapped in a sail bag. She is notable for her dark hair dyed with a purple streak, mimicking the color of the island’s poisonous nightshade flower. While mainland homicide detectives, led by Stilwell’s former rival Ahearn, arrive to take control of the case, they are quick to pursue convenient leads that fit a simple narrative.

Stilwell, adhering to the code that “everybody counts or nobody counts,” refuses to stand down. He conducts a rogue investigation that reveals a connection between the murder and the buffalo mutilation. As he digs deeper, he unearths a conspiracy driven by the island’s powerful elite, including the manager of the exclusive Black Marlin Club and the local Mayor. Their motive is rooted in the preservation of the island’s lucrative tourism economy, which they believe would be threatened by a scandalous murder investigation. Stilwell’s pursuit of the truth exposes a web of corruption, kickbacks, and cover-ups, proving that even in paradise, dangerous secrets fester.

Overview of the Characters

Detective Sergeant Stilwell (“Stil”): The novel’s protagonist is a tenacious and ethical detective. Viewed as a “misfit” by the department brass, he finds a strange kinship with the isolated island. He is driven by a relentless desire for justice, even when it jeopardizes his career.
Tash Dano: The assistant harbormaster and Stilwell’s romantic interest. As a Catalina native, she represents the “insider” perspective, deeply connected to the island’s history and traditions. Her relationship with Stilwell highlights the tension between his duty and her community.
Leigh-Anne Moss: The murder victim. A young woman on the margins of the island’s high society, her death becomes the catalyst for exposing the rot beneath the surface.
Mayor Douglas Allen: The antagonist representing institutional corruption. He prioritizes business interests and the island’s image over justice.
Charles Crane: The manager of the Black Marlin Club, representing the entitled, wealthy class that believes they are above the law.
Detective Ahearn: A mainland detective who serves as a foil to Stilwell, representing the bureaucratic and political obstacles within law enforcement.

Overview of the Themes

Insider vs. Outsider The island setting creates a natural boundary between “locals” and “mainlanders.” Stilwell captures the friction of being an outsider trying to police a tight-knit community where everyone knows each other’s business and protects their own. The island is depicted almost as a living character that resists external scrutiny.

Corruption vs. Justice A central theme is the conflict between economic survival and moral duty. The island’s leaders are willing to obstruct justice to maintain the veneer of a safe tourist haven. The novel questions the cost of prosperity when it requires silencing the truth.

“Everybody Counts or Nobody Counts” Echoing the moral compass of Harry Bosch, Stilwell champions the forgotten victim. Despite Leigh-Anne Moss’s troubled life and lack of social standing, Stilwell treats her case with the utmost seriousness, reinforcing the idea that justice should not be means-tested.

Conclusion

“Nightshade” successfully establishes a fresh landscape for Michael Connelly’s crime universe. By shifting the focus to the unique geography and social dynamics of Catalina Island, the novel offers a new flavor of noir while retaining the procedural excellence fans expect. The resolution sees Stilwell exposing the conspiracy and bringing the guilty to justice, but the victory comes with the realization that the island’s beauty hides enduring dangers. It is a compelling start to the Catalina series, setting the stage for future cases for Detective Stilwell.

Sources

[1] Kirkus Reviews: https://www.kirkusreviews.com/news-and-features/articles/new-novel-by-michael-connelly-coming-this-spring/
[2] SoBrief: https://sobrief.com/books/nightshade-6
[3] Washington Independent Review of Books: https://www.washingtonindependentreviewofbooks.com/bookreview/nightshade